What it is and why it sells
Polymeric sand is ordinary joint sand blended with binding polymers that harden once water activates them, turning the joint into a semi-rigid mass. It was sold as the end of sand erosion and weeds, and in a moderate climate that is roughly what it delivers. Its whole performance envelope assumes a clean, dry installation and clean, dry maintenance.
Why the Florida version goes wrong
Neither condition holds here reliably, because summer humidity keeps the sand from curing through if it goes in during the wrong window, and rain inside the first 24 hours of activation flushes the polymers out before they bond. The worse problem comes later: once polymeric sand has partially failed, which in our field experience is the normal outcome, taking it out is far harder than taking out regular sand, because polymer residue contaminates the joint, fresh sand will not bond into it, and sealer will not penetrate the way it should. Activation carries its own risk, since the binders can haze onto the adjacent paver face and leave a film visible from standing height, and the remedy is an acid wash, which is its own hazard on travertine, marble, and color-treated concrete.
When it is the right call
The answer is not universal and we will not pretend otherwise. On some high-traffic commercial pavers with a predictable maintenance schedule, and on certain pedestrian-only installations under cover, polymeric sand earns its place, and if yours is one of those we will say so. On everything else we use polymer-free sand and let the sealer bind the joint, which keeps it reversible.